Choose from one of our delicious flavors (regular or gluten-free):
Sold by the dozen.

Mom's Chocolate Chip:
In loving memory of Sue Raimer (1959–2021)
Soft‑centered, lightly crisp, and filled with melty chocolate, these cookies celebrate the recipe Sue passed down with joy. Each batch is a small tribute to her kindness, her creativity, and the way she made every treat feel like home.

Original Oatmeal:
A timeless favorite, our Original Oatmeal Cookies blend rustic texture with melt‑in‑your‑mouth warmth. They’re irresistibly comforting—expect smiles, crumbs, and grateful little thank‑you's from the moment you serve them.

Spicy Oatmeal Molasses:
A wholesome blend of rolled oats, molasses, and warming spices creates a cookie that’s naturally flavorful and deeply aromatic. Soft, chewy, and made with simple ingredients, these cookies offer a cozy, satisfying bite without anything artificial.

Sugar:
Made with simple ingredients and baked to a soft, tender crumb, our Sugar Cookies offer pure, uncomplicated sweetness. Their delicate texture and warm vanilla aroma make them a timeless favorite for every cookie lover.

Old‑Town Molasses:
A throwback to classic Midwestern bakery traditions — deeply spiced, rich with molasses, and impossibly soft. Made with warm spices and a generous pour of molasses.

Delicate Citrus:
Soft little clouds of sunshine — lightly sweet, impossibly airy, and lifted with the fresh, fragrant zest of real oranges. Made with Greek yogurt for a tender, melt‑away crumb, these cookies feel weightless in your hand and even lighter on the palate. Each batch is hand‑mixed in small Side Yard batches, giving them their signature soft texture and bright citrus aroma.

Snickerdoodle:
Cinnamon and sugar, our Snickerdoodles bake up soft and tender with a delicate crumb. Pure, simple ingredients — classic snickerdoodle flavor.

Iced Lemon:
Our Iced Lemon Sugar Cookies are soft, tender, and bursting with fresh lemon zest. Each cookie is topped with a silky lemon glaze that adds the perfect sweet‑tart finish. Light, bright, and melt‑in‑your‑mouth soft — a sunny little treat in every bite.

We are very careful with ingredients, especially since we've had previous ingredient restrictions. Please be aware that our kitchen handles a variety of items, including nuts and wheat. If you have any food allergies, let us know so we can take every reasonable precaution. However, we cannot guarantee that any product will be completely free from potential allergens.